Anal Toy Styles Built for Every Kind of Play

Anal Toy Styles Built for Every Kind of Play

by Jacee Niblett - May 1, 2025

When most people hear "anal toys," their minds go straight to butt plugs—and hey, there’s a reason they’re the classic go-to, But plugs are just the tip of the iceberg. Anal play has so much more to offer than one single shape or style, and if that’s all you’re familiar with, you might be seriously missing out.

There’s a whole world of anal toys out there, designed with different sensations, experiences, and bodies in mind. Whether you're looking for something subtle, something intense, or something in between, there's likely a toy that fits your unique wants and needs. Just like with any other kind of toy, exploring different options can open the door to more pleasure, deeper connection with your body, and a better understanding of what you truly enjoy.

So if you're feeling curious, adventurous, or just plain ready to level up your pleasure game, let's dive into a few of the lesser-known (but seriously awesome) anal toys you might want to try.

Beaded Toys

I love recommending beaded anal toys - for a variety of reasons or occasions. For one, they offer a bit more of a diverse experience compared to classic plugs. There’s more movement in the sensation than just wearing an accessory, if you know what I mean. The sensation of the beads moving in or out can provide a whole new world of stimulation!

But another reason to try them out is if you’re looking to explore anal play with low commitment. With a butt plug, you’re really all in or you’re out. But with a beaded toy like this one by Calexotics - you can test the waters with just the first bead before moving gradually down the shaft with the bigger beads. This really gives you the chance to relax, explore, and find what you like.

So check out the Cheeky Beads by Calexotics for a new sensation in the world of anal.

Cheeky™ X-6 Beads

Prostate Toys

If your anatomy includes a prostate, enhancing your repertoire with something that includes prostate stimulation can be a game changer. The classic butt plug style does not reach the prostate effectively, so getting something specifically designed for the task is essential to stimulate that area.

Take the Admiral by Calexotics for example - with its tapered and curved design it’s the perfect shape for reaching that area. Plus, the powerful vibrating motor adds an intense level of pleasure that you just can’t get with a basic butt plug.

If you’re looking for a brand new type of anal stimulation, a prostate toy is the way to go!

Admiral™ Advanced Curved Probe

Pegging / Strap Ons

If it’s your cup of tea - a fantastic way to experience anal play is during partnered sex, and just one of many ways to do that is by utilizing a strap on dildo. In other words - pegging!

Just like with any form of anal play, you have to find a size and style that works for you. Again, for those with prostates something curved is always going to be a great option. This Pegging Probe by Calexotics is a gorgeous choice because it’s slim, smooth, and slightly curved. It fits nicely in any O-ring harness and is compatible with any water based lubricant.

This is a great choice for any beginner pegging set-up, or for anyone who prefers a gentle easy dildo for their strap on.

Silicone Pegging Probe

There’s more to life than scripted sex - and there’s more to anal play than the classic butt plug style. Depending on your preferences and adventurous spirit, one of these options might be better suited for you.

Taking different designs into consideration when shopping for a new toy is vital - because getting the more effective and desired stimulation is paramount to your pleasure.

So don’t be afraid to try something new, and as always:

Be safe and have fun!