Butt Plugs

Camp Hill
Harrisburg
King of Prussia
Reading
York
Excitement Loyalty
Events
About Us
Jobs
Looking for Smoke Products?

Currency

Australia (USD $)
Belgium (USD $)
Canada (USD $)
Costa Rica (USD $)
Finland (USD $)
France (USD $)
Germany (USD $)
Greece (USD $)
Greenland (USD $)
Iceland (USD $)
Ireland (USD $)
Israel (USD $)
Italy (USD $)
Japan (USD $)
Latvia (USD $)
Netherlands (USD $)
New Zealand (USD $)
Norway (USD $)
Poland (USD $)
Singapore (USD $)
South Korea (USD $)
Sweden (USD $)
Switzerland (USD $)
Taiwan (USD $)
U.S. Outlying Islands (USD $)
United Kingdom (USD $)
United States (USD $)

New Products
On Sale
Shop All
Vibrators
Dildos
Anal Toys
Penis Play
Lubes & More
Sexual Wellness
Bondage & Fetish
Lingerie
More
Free Gift
Staff Favorites
Recently Restocked

New Products
On Sale
Shop All
Vibrators
Beginner-Friendly Vibrators
Clitoral Vibrators
Rabbit Vibrators
Air Stimulation Vibrators
G-Spot Vibrators
Bullet Vibrators
Discreet Vibrators
Wand Massagers
Wearable Vibrators
Shop all Vibrators
Dildos
Beginner-Friendly Dildos
Realistic Dildos
Silicone Dildos
Metal Dildos
Glass Dildos
Strap-On Dildos and Harnesses
Shop all Dildos
Anal Toys
Beginner-Friendly Anal Toys
Advanced Play Anal Toys
Anal Beads
Butt Plugs
Inflatable Anal Toys
Prostate Toys
Douches & Enemas
Shop all Anal Toys
Penis Play
Electronic Masturbators
Strokers
Penis Rings
Extenders & Sleeves
Pumps
Dolls & Molds
Condoms
Shop all Penis Play
Lubes & More
Lubricants
Toy Cleaners
Oral Enhancers
Bathware
Sexy Gifts and Toys
Shop all Lubes & More
Sexual Wellness
Kegels
Condoms
Bulk Condoms
Massage
Sexual Stimulants
Shop all Sexual Wellness
Bondage & Fetish
Bondage Kits
Cuffs & Restraints
Blindfolds and Gags
Floggers/Whips/Spankers
Sensation Play
Furniture & Machines
Shop all Bondage & Furniture
Lingerie
Lingerie and Accessories
Dancewear
Costume Sets
Stockings and Hosiery
Men's Underwear
Shoes
Shop all Lingerie and Shoes
More
Games and Books
Pins
Plushies
Beverages
Gift Cards
Shop all Fun Stuff
Free Gift
Staff Favorites
Recently Restocked
Camp Hill
Harrisburg
King of Prussia
Reading
York
Excitement Loyalty
Events
About Us
Jobs
Looking for Smoke Products?

New Products
On Sale
Shop All
Vibrators
Dildos
Anal Toys
Penis Play
Lubes & More
Sexual Wellness
Bondage & Fetish
Lingerie
More
- More
- Games and Books
- Pins
- Plushies
- Beverages
- Gift Cards
- Shop all Fun Stuff
Free Gift
Staff Favorites
Recently Restocked

Camp Hill
Harrisburg
King of Prussia
Reading
York
Excitement Loyalty
Events
About Us
Jobs
Looking for Smoke Products?
Register / Login

United States (USD $)

Your cart

Your cart is empty

Not sure where to start? Check out some of our favorites!

Staff Favorites

Check out some of our favorite things!

Staff Favorites

Designed with a tapered tip for easy insertion and a flared base or string for safety, butt plugs come with a variety of features such as vibration, remote control, inflation, or just something with some bling. Whether you're a beginner seeking added stimulation or an experienced user wanting more intense orgasms, you're sure to find the plug for you.

Beginner-Friendly Anal Toys

Advanced Play Anal Toys

Anal Beads

Butt Plugs

Inflatable Anal Toys

Prostate Toys

Douches and Enemas

Anal Lube

926 Results

Featured
Most relevant
Best selling
Alphabetically, A-Z
Alphabetically, Z-A
Price, low to high
Price, high to low
Date, old to new
Date, new to old

Clear filters

Bunny Tails Mini Silicone Butt Plug - Pink Fur - Black/Pink

No reviews

Bunny Tails Mini Silicone Butt Plug - Pink Fur

$36.99

Unit price: per

1 color

Booty Sparks Lucky Clover Gem Medium Anal Plug - Green - Medium

No reviews

Booty Sparks Lucky Clover Gem Medium Anal Plug

$36.99

Unit price: per

1 color

Booty Sparks Gemstones Red Jasper Hearts Anal Plug - Metal/Red - 3 Pieces/Set

No reviews

Booty Sparks Gemstones Red Jasper Hearts Anal Plug

$79.99

Unit price: per

1 color

Anal Adventures Platinum Silicone Anal Plug with Vibrating Cock Ring - Black

No reviews

Anal Adventures Platinum Silicone Anal Plug with Vibrating Cock Ring

$38.99

Unit price: per

1 color

Anal Adventures Platinum Silicone Beginner Plug - Black - Small

No reviews

Anal Adventures Platinum Silicone Beginner Plug

from $13.99

Unit price: per

1 color

Creature Cocks Sinister Eyes Red Eye Metal Butt Plug Set

No reviews

Creature Cocks Sinister Eyes Red Eye Metal Butt Plug Set

$62.99

Unit price: per

Creature Cocks Creature Eyes Green Eye Silicone Butt Plug Set

No reviews

Creature Cocks Creature Eyes Green Eye Silicone Butt Plug Set

$42.99

Unit price: per

The 9's CottonTails Silicone Bunny Tail Anal Plug

No reviews

The 9's CottonTails Silicone Bunny Tail Anal Plug

$19.99

Unit price: per

1 color

CalExotics Jewel Amethyst Heart Anal Plug

No reviews

CalExotics Jewel Amethyst Heart Anal Plug

from $19.99

Unit price: per

2 sizes

No reviews

Glams Xchange Round Anal Plug

from $12.99

Unit price: per

2 sizes

No reviews

Rear Assets Heart Gem Anal Plug

from $22.99

Unit price: per

1 size

No reviews

Crystal Flower Glass Plug

$36.99

Unit price: per

1 color

Booty Sparks Glow In The Dark Glass Anal Plug

No reviews

Booty Sparks Glow In The Dark Glass Anal Plug

$44.99

Unit price: per

1 size

b-Vibe Expand and Vibrating Remote Control Plug

No reviews

b-Vibe Expand and Vibrating Remote Control Plug

$169.99

Unit price: per

Whipsmart Furry Tales Silicone Unicorn Butt Plug

No reviews

Whipsmart Furry Tales Silicone Unicorn Butt Plug

$64.99

Unit price: per

b-Vibe 360 Plug Rechargeable Silicone Rotating and Vibrating with Remote Anal Plug

No reviews

b-Vibe 360 Plug Rechargeable Silicone Rotating and Vibrating with Remote Anal Plug

$169.99

Unit price: per

1 color

No reviews

Envy Thumbs Up Remote Controlled P-Spot Vibrator and Dual Stamina Ring

$129.99

Unit price: per

Boundless™ 2X Teardrop Plug

$14.99

Unit price: per

Luxe Night Rimmer Kit Anal Plug With Handle Black

No reviews

Luxe Night Rimmer Kit Anal Plug With Handle

$48.99

Unit price: per

1 color

No reviews

B Yours Basic 4" Anal Plug

$12.99

Unit price: per

1 color

You’re viewing 61-80 of 926 products

Sort

Featured
Most relevant
Best selling
Alphabetically, A-Z
Alphabetically, Z-A
Price, low to high
Price, high to low
Date, old to new
Date, new to old

Shop Top Anal Toy Brands

Our staff is truly what sets us apart from the rest and makes our site and stores the ideal spot for adult shopping. We are staffed with educated, well-informed, and open-minded individuals who truly hold a passion for what we do.

YES/NO/MAYBE

At Excitement, we believe that fun and safe sexual scenarios start with a good conversation.

The Yes/No/Maybe list is a tool amongst the Kink and Pleasure communities to discuss your sexual interests efficiently and without judgment or pleasure. Click the link to get started.

Download now!

SHOP

Search
Shop All
Shop Sale Items
Gift Cards
Blog
Events

Locations

Excitement Camp Hill - 3401 Hartzdale Dr., Camp Hill, PA 17011
Excitement Harrisburg - 3910 Jonestown Rd., Harrisburg, PA 17109
Excitement King of Prussia - 143 S Gulph Rd #140, King of Prussia, PA 19406
Excitement Reading - 2396 Lancaster Pike, Reading, PA 19607
Excitement York - 925 Loucks Rd., York, PA 17404

Policies & Legal

Contact Us
Exchange and Return Policy
Shipping Info
Privacy Policy
2257 Compliance
Terms of Service
Jobs
Loyalty and Rewards

Your email

Currency

Australia (USD $)
Belgium (USD $)
Canada (USD $)
Costa Rica (USD $)
Finland (USD $)
France (USD $)
Germany (USD $)
Greece (USD $)
Greenland (USD $)
Iceland (USD $)
Ireland (USD $)
Israel (USD $)
Italy (USD $)
Japan (USD $)
Latvia (USD $)
Netherlands (USD $)
New Zealand (USD $)
Norway (USD $)
Poland (USD $)
Singapore (USD $)
South Korea (USD $)
Sweden (USD $)
Switzerland (USD $)
Taiwan (USD $)
U.S. Outlying Islands (USD $)
United Kingdom (USD $)
United States (USD $)

Availability

This Product is added in your cart

Its visible if you added $89 (or more) to your cart. After that, this product will be added automatically to your cart.

{"themeColor":"#ef1516","iconColor":"#ef1516","showLogo":true,"topBottomPosition":10,"rightLeftPosition":10,"iconSize":"small","iconCustomSize":40,"position":"bottom-right"}